| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |

Random Womble
Minmatar Master Miners
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 13:42:00 -
[1]
what i find ammusing is you are just sticking to BSs vs dreads diffrence i mean if you get cruisers vs BS you would not expect 100 cruisers to kill 100 BS and yet that is less diffrence in size terms than what you are talking about. Ingeneral BSs Vs Dreads now Post QR and the web nerf dreads are going to be very hard pressed to actually do damage to moving BSs except for their drones (if you know your going to fight dreads a few smart bombs might be useful they do have a limited supply of drones about 1 wave of heavys for a phoenix). Dreads also have huge difficultys locking BSs as has been mentioned before due to the 2 target lock limit and the long lock time when in siege (out of siege dread guns are so ineffective there is no point in using them really). Finally dreads are very inflexiable they have 2 real roles killing POSs and killing other caps (which can be done by carriers anyway) to do this they have to stay in position not moving rely solely on their own tank which tbh in fights dreads get used in makes no diffrence and in smaller fights they can be neuted to death without too much trouble. While a BS can choose to disengage, attack a variety of diffrent targets (try going roaming with a dread to kill people that might be funny ratter in belt drop cyno siege dread take a minute or more to lock target....) and generally are more flexiable if anything what dreads could do with is a huge boost to their tanking abilitys so they can tank more than one other dread but leave them just as vulnerable as they are now to a few neuts make support a requirement to kill them, most current dread tanks are not cap stable anyway.
|

Random Womble
Minmatar Master Miners
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 22:35:00 -
[2]
Edited by: Random Womble on 24/12/2008 22:37:17
Originally by: Deva Blackfire
Originally by: Random Womble
rest of wall of text
So you are saying that cap ship blobs are fine? And everyone enjoys being one of 100-200-300 whatever caps you can bring?
Also if you are being one hard-pressed by dread blob there is no option of "let them be, we will come for them later". They are used primarily as offensive tool and nowadays cap blobs are sure way to go. Why? Because smaller enemy (be it corp/alliance) can not hope to counter it without sizeable cap fleet at their disposal.
Sorry about wall effect was in a rush.
TBH its not cap blobs that are a problem its any blobs dreads are used as an offensive tool yes but not for just general fights they are used to take out POSs which is what they were designed to do or other capitals occasionally. Its not dreads that need fixing its the general way gameplay is that does. That smaller corp/allaince might well be able to field the same number of caps/member but its overall numbers that matter if they were all fighting in battleships the small corp/alliance would still be in the same position when big group brings a battleship blob instead.
Plus if dreads had better tanks the smaler group would actually benifit if they managed to kill off all the hostile support then used their own support to neut the Hostile dreads tanks to death while their dreads remain alive to help do the required DPS.
|

Random Womble
Minmatar Master Miners
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 22:43:00 -
[3]
Originally by: Kagura Nikon
The only thing needed to solve the "issue" you present is removign the stupid DD. Then if you field 100 dreads against 1/4 of the same isk value in battleships. The battleships would simply waste the dreads unless the dread size deploys enough support to "control the field"
if you fight 100 dreads with 1/4 of the same isk in battleships you are looking at fielding around 3-500 BS (dread cost + mods and rigs 1.5-2bil depending on inhouse production or not insurace can be bought for both ship classes so is not relavent to calculations).
|

Random Womble
Minmatar Master Miners
|
Posted - 2008.12.24 22:52:00 -
[4]
Originally by: Deva Blackfire Thing is: you CAN win the fight if you have 25% of enemy numbers while heaviest ship used is battleship. Sniper BS/support dies so easily that even doing warp in-kill one-warp out strafe runs will win you a fight. With caps it just doesnt work. Neither caps can do strafe runs vs other caps nor BS will be able to kill one and warp off before getting blobbed to hell and back.
Yeh main point here is the total amount of HP caps have nowadays. Back before caps got HP boosted it was possible to snipe em and GTFO, nowadays it just isnt. You need to stay on field and "stay on field" gameplay is almost always won by bigger blob.
Capital HP boost was need i mean you could boost more HPs with a capital booster than you could have thats just silly and being able to instapop capitals with relatively small sniping fleets was overpowered. As people have said you still can kill a dread before he can lock you back even with what now would be considered a moderately sized gang.
|

Random Womble
Minmatar Master Miners
|
Posted - 2008.12.25 11:47:00 -
[5]
Edited by: Random Womble on 25/12/2008 11:47:22
Originally by: Deva Blackfire
Originally by: Kagura Nikon
Remote rep does not work on dreads on siege. And if you even start talking about dreads fighting out of siege you are just making yourself look dumb (sorry but its the truth)
Welcome to the "i ran out of the arguments, need to insult" world. Why exactly is it stupid? Because you can actually hit something? Because your guns still deal nice damage? Because you CAN be remote repped?
We all know sieged dread suck vs anything that isnt capital or pos so why you insist on using sieged dread vs subcaps? See - i guess your lots of dread piloting experience ends with "f1 lock, f2, pos dead, cyno out". Try something else and yes it does work. And works even better if you have moros (sentries on that ship rock if you didnt know, and no need to siege at all).
Other than the Moros (which is way overpowered compaired with other dreads) dreads out of siege do abour 500-600 DPS then add in the fact that the XL guns/cit torps still have pretty bad tracking/explosion velocity using them out of siege just is not worth it you want do do stuff out of siege you use carriers. Plus even if dreads are out of siege they wont fit any remote reps yes any carriers with them will but then your changing the balance of the equation your no longer talking about 100 dreads your talking about a whole mixed bag. Your complaint was about dreads on their own against sub caps but now your changing your story to try and get around the arguements given by others as to why you are wrong.
Also the other guy was right as far as i can tell you have never flown a dread nothing you have said even hints at it.
|
| |
|